Dietary Cation-Anion Balances in Poultry

Established bird maintenance and production req. based on:

Energy (carbohydrates and  Fat), Protein, Vitamins and Minerals. 

 Recent Trends:    Subdivision of major nutrients into more specific subclasses, e.g.,

          Carbohydrates:   Structural and Non-structural

          Protein:               Amino acids (Lysine and methionine)

         Minerals:             Macro and Micro (on the basis of quantity)

Minerals Importance:

Part of all biological functions;

  • structural role
  • expression and regulation of genes
  • hormone and enzyme systems
  • osmotic balance, and
  • acid base balance

AIM: Focus on the balance of fixed dietary cation and anions on acid-base balance and its potential effects on performance in poultry birds reared in thermoneutral and heat stress environments.

AIM: 

Focus on the balance of fixed dietary cation and anions on acid-base balance and its potential effects on performance in poultry birds reared in thermoneutral and heat stress environments

ELECTROLYTES

Substances which when added to the neutral water, produces a conductor solution.

  • Strong electrolytes (HCl, NaCl, NaOH)
  • Weak electrolytes (NH3, CH3COOH, HgCl2)

Electrolyte Concentrations in Body Fluids

 

Extracellular

Intracellular

Cations(+)

mEq/l

mEq/l

Na+

142

10

K+

5

140

Ca2+

5

0.1

Mg2+

3

30

Anions(-)

   

HCO3

27

10

Cl

103

4

HPO42-

2

60

SO42-

1

 

Organic acids

6

NA

Proteins

2

16

(Gamble, 1954)

Diet and Electrolyte Balance:

High concentrate diet?

High forage diet?

                                      (Roby et al., 1987)

Ration Cation-Anion Balancing

Ill defined terminology:

          Anion gap, alkali-alkalinity,          acidity-alkalinity,        and

          dietary cation- anion balance (DCAB)

Concept of balancing DCAB in poultry was given by Mongin (1981).

 

Fixed cations and anions

Bioavailable ions which can not be metabolized or broken down further during digestion/metabolic processes.

 

– Fixed ion balance determines the acid base balance in biological fluids.

(Stewart, 1978)

Sodium, Potassium and Chlorine are considered as Fixed ions because;

  • Osmotic balance
  • Acid base balance
  • Pumping mechanism of cell membranes

Fixed dietary ion balance: (mEq) (Na++K+)-(Cl)

 

DCAB:      Does not determine dietary acido- or alkalo-genic properties.

But affect metabolic processes by;

                       –  Kidney function, buffering system & cellular maintenance.

 

Relationship Between Acid Base Balance

and Mineral Balance in Practice

When animal in steady a state

(Blood pH 7.4, Plasma carbonate 25 mEq/l, BE=0)

(An-Cat)in + H+endo – (An-Cat)out = 0…………..1

 

(An-Cat)in + H+endo – (An-Cat)out + BE = 0………2

(Cat-An)in – (Cat-An)out – H+endo = BE ……………3

(Cat-An)in = mEq (Na+ + K+ + Ca2+ + Mg2+) – mEq (Cl

+ SO42- + H2PO4- + HPO4 2-)…………………….4

(Cat-An)in = mEq (Na + K -Cl) + mEq (Ca + Mg – SO – H2PO – HPO4)…..5

(Na + K – Cl) = (Cat-An)out + H+endo + BE……………..6

Practical Importance of Mineral Balance

 

  1. Acid base balance and its relationship to the (Na+K-Cl) balance

          Blood acid base balance µ Ionic balance of the diet

Relationship between the (Na+K-Cl) content of the diet and plasma bicarbonate concentrations in growing chicks

                                                (Mongin and Sauveur, 1973)

  1. Mineral Balance and Body Growth

Maximum body weight gain at DACB 250 mEq/100g

 

Effect of (Na+K-Cl) content of the diet of body weight at 4 weeks of age in chicks.

 

(Meilliere and Forbes, 1966; Hurwitz et al., 1973; Mongin and Sauveur, 1973, 1977)

  1. Endogenous Acid Production and Protein Source

 

 

  1. The composition of the nitrogen products varies
  2. Organic phosphate increases the H+ production
  3. Mineral composition of natural protein sources is highly variable

Variation in the (Na+K-Cl) content of the diet when part of the soya is substituted by another protein source

Protein sources used

Percentage of soya/percentage of other protein source in the overall diet

 

20/0

17/2

14/4

8/8

 

(Na+K-Cl) content of the diet (mEq/100g)

Soybean meal (50%)/

Fish meal (75%)

17.42

16.35

15.27

13.13

Soybean meal (50%)/

Meat meal (50%)

17.42

16.42

15.41

13.41

Soybean meal (50%)/

Sunflower meal (42.5%)

17.42

16.82

16.26

15.10

(Mongin, 1980)

Divalent Cation Intake and Bird Performance

Effects of Hydrochloride and Chloride Salts on Feed Consumption and Growth

Treat.

Dietary additive

Chloride added

Cat/An

Feed cons/ chick/d (g)

Gain/d

(g)

1

none

1

1.2

18.0

11.5

2

HCl

0.28

1.1

16.5

10.6

3

HCl

.58

1.0

16.3

9.7

4

HCl

2.41

0.6

6.8

1.1

5

CaCl2.2H2O

2.41

 

8.3

2.1

6

MgCl2.6H2O

2.41

 

13.2

6.3

7

NaCl+KCl

2.41

 

16.9

10.9

1 Basal diet with 1.047% chloride and DCAB 150 meq/kg

(Melliere and Forbes, 1966)

Effects of Excess Dietary Na, K or the Combination on Feed Consumption and Growth

Treat.

Dietary additive

Cat/An

Feed cons/ chick/d (g)

Gain/d

(g)

1

none1

1.2

18.0

11.5

2

Na (0.279)

1.4

18.1

12.4

3

Na (0.972)

1.8

17.3

12.0

4

Na (1.649)

2.2

14.1  (3)

9.4

5

K (0.477)

1.4

17.7

11.4

6

K (1.560)

1.8

17.6

10.9

7

K (1.649)

2.2

15.6

9.0

8

Na+K2

1.4

17.6

11.6

9

Na+K

1.8

18.0

11.0

10

Na+K

2.2

17.1

10.9

1 Basal diet with 1.047% chloride and DCAB 150 meq/kg

2 added as carbonate in equimolar conc.

(Melliere and Forbes, 1966)

Effect of Chloride, Sulphate and Phosphate on Blood Acid-Base Variables

Anion added

Amount added

Body wt.

Feed intake

Blood variables

H+          HCO3         pCO2

 

mEq/kg

(g)

g/chick

(10-8 M)

(mM)

(mm Hg)

None

0

95.6ab

94.4a

4.02 (7.40)1

17.2

28.3

Cl

160

87.5bc

76.0

5.29 (7.28)**

12.8**

27.5

Cl

240

83.5c

71.0c

5.88 (7.23)**

11.1**

25.8

SO4

120

101.5a

92.1a

4.50 (7.35)*

14.6**

30.0

SO4

240

101.6a

90.9ab

4.52 (7.34)*2

13.8**2

26.4

PO4

120

99.7a

86.3abc

4.29 (7.37)

16.1

29.2

PO4

240

98.6ab

90.4ab

7.06 (7.39)2

16.62

28.6

1 pH in parenthesis                        

2 Significantly different form 240 mEq/kg Cl treatment (P<0.05)

* Significantly different from 0 mEq/kg treatment (P<0.05).

**Significantly different from 0 mEq/kg treatment (P<0.01).

                                                                                                (Austic et al., 1993)

Effects of Electrolyte on Growth of Heat Distressed broilers

Adverse Effects of High Temp Includes;

  1. Reduced feed intake
  2. Reduction in weight gain
  3. Increased mortality

(Teeter et al., 1994; Reece et al., 1985)

Which are due to changes in ;

  1. Intestinal flora (Suzuki et al., 1983)
  2. Amino acid digestibility (Wallis and Bawlnave, 1984)      
  3. Immune function (Thaxton and Siegel, 1970)
  4. Blood acid base balance (Mitchel and Siegell, 1973)

How to counteract these changes

  1. Addition of electrolytes in water (KCl, NaCl, NaHCO3,)
  2. Addition of electrolytes in feed (KCl, NaCl, NH4Cl, NaHCO3,)

Effect of Electrolytes Addition in Water on Broiler Performance Reared at Elevated Temperature  (22C to 35C) from 22 to 49 d of Age

Parameters

Control

KCl

(0.48%)

NaCl

(0.376%)

BW gain (g/d)

44.0b

45.3ab

46.7a

Feed consump. (g/d)

118

113

119

Water consump. (ml/d)

210b

247a

255a

Body temp. (C)

43.1

43.0

43.1

Carcass weight (g)

1398

1400

1467

Carcass yield (%)

68.7

69.1

69.5

Abdominal fat   (%)

1.76

1.84

1.87

pH

7.3

7.2

7.29

Survivability

88c

97a

93b

a,b,cMeans within the same row differ significantly (P<0.05)

(Smith, 1994)

(Deyhim and Teeter, 1991)

High Chronic Ambient Temperature Stress and Birds Response to Supplemental NH4Cl, KCl and K2CO3

 

K+

(%)

NH4Cl

       0                   0.1                0.3                0.5         

Av.daily gain, g

       
 

0

17.9efg

19.2cde

18.5def

16.8fg

 

0.05

18.5def

21.6ab

19.0cde

16.4b

 

.1

19.8bcd

21.7ab

20.6bc

14.5h

 

.5

21.2b

23.1a

17.1fg

12.6i

Gain/feed

0

0.29a

0.31a

0.27a

0.291a

 

0.05

0.30a

0.32a

0.29a

0.27a

 

.1

0.30a

0.29a

0.32a

0.25a

 

.5

0.31a

0.31a

0.27a

0.18b

Blood pH

0

7.45a

7.33bc

7.25cde

7.17efg

 

0.05

7.39ab

7.27cd

7.23de

7.14fgh

 

.1

7.41ab

7.27cd

7.19def

7.16fg

 

.5

7.40ab

7.17efg

7.09gh

7.07h

a-iMeans within a parameter with unlike superscript differ significantly (P<0.05)

Water Suppl. K+ (%)

Av.daily gain (g)

Gain/feed

0

23.1b

0.26

.15 K+ as KCl

27.4a

0.32

.15 K+ as K2CO3

18.6c

0.24

(Teeter and Smith, 1986)

Heat Stress and Layer Performance

Egg shell formation:

Dietary calcium + Bone —— (PTH)——-> Egg shell formation

During Shell formation —- > ¯ in blood & uterine fluid pH—- > carbonate formation by shell glands — > acidosis — > hyperventilation and acidic urine.

NaHCO3 improve the situation but not improve shell quality.

When (Na + K) -Cl >1.5   ——– > no drop in pH but at ratio 2 respiratory alkalosis. Increasing Cl improved the shell quality.

Under heat stress (32-40C):

Panting —– > loss of CO2 — > respiratory alkalosis — (negative Na and K balance)…..Blood ionined calcium level decreases —-> disturbed acid base balance —- > poor shell formation.

Remedies

Sodium bicarbonate supplementation (water @ .2-.5%/feed @ .5-1.5%)  and/or 0.6% KCl in water will improve the situation.

Whereas KHCO3 aggravated respiratory alaklosis.

Intake of Ions and Wetness of Droppings

Water intake and weight of wet droppings as a function of

potassium intake

Sodium and Sodium Bicarbonate Utilisation by Broiler Chicks

Trt

Supp. Na

Final BW

Av. daily intake

Feed           Water       Sodium

Faecal moisture

(%)

(mg/kg)

————(g)———-

(mg)

(%)

NaCl

           

0

0

99a

11.2a

15.4a

3.3a

33.6a

.05

196

170b

19.9b

28.4bc

9.9b

64.7b

.10

392

247c

24.1c

34.7cd

16.7c

72.7b

.15

588

347d

29.4d

46.4ef

26.2d

74.7b

NaHCO3

           

.072

196

177b

19.1b

25.8b

9.5b

75.7b

.144

392

279c

26.1cd

39.6de

18.0c

76.1b

.216

588

347d

28.1cd

49.5fg

25.0d

76.3b

a-gMeans in the same column without common letter differ significantly. (P<0.05)

(Damron et al., 1986)

Limitations 

  • Where the rate of inclusion in the diet of one of the minerals in question is less than the birds minimum requirements.
  • DCAB have little effect when one of the minerals is present in such excess that it becomes toxic.
  • The ratio of K/(Na-Cl) must be higher than unity in order to avoid mortality in chicks.
  • DCAB must be kept as close as possible to 250 mEq/kg of the diet to met K/(NA-Cl) >1.

 Conclusions

  • Anions are acidogenic while cations are alkalogenic. Excess cations/anions depressed the wt gain and feed consumption. 
  • PO4 (150 mEq/kg) [in contrast to PO4-2 (900-1200 mEq/kg)] is a strong acidic anion and reduces performance and egg shell quality, which can be alleviated by alkaline salts of Na or K bicarbonates.

 Water intake and faeces moisture content increases with high DCAB (mEq/kg. 170 vs 340).

 2 % NH4Cl or 0.15 % KCl in drinking water alleviates adverse effects of heat stress and improved bird performance (wt gain: 23 and 46%, feed efficiency: 7.7 and 15.4%, respectively).

 Better performance with the DCAB of 250 mEq/kg of diet.

 The potassium content of the diet must be higher than 12.5 mEq/100 g, and the (Na-Cl ) content must be lower than 12.5 mEq/100 g.

 Need further investigations.

Need reference, write to us.